Back to Blog
The Loyalty Illusion: Why Great Teams Give People a Reason to Stay
Ask someone what they like about their job, and there's a good chance they'll bring up their team before they mention a specific project. Maybe it's how everyone pitches in when a deadline gets tight. Or it's the quick chat with a teammate that turns a rough Monday around. Those everyday moments add up, and they're a big part of why work can feel like a place you want to be.
A strong team can also be a place to talk about bigger things, like where you’d like to grow next. When that doesn’t feel easy, a question like “Would I stay if the perfect opportunity came along?” tends to stay private, and the rest of the team may never know it’s there.
Wiley Workplace Intelligence surveyed 1,600 employees to learn more about what's behind their plans to stay. We asked how likely they are to be with their employer a year from now, what keeps them there, and whether they'd stay if the job market were ideal. We also asked how comfortable they feel being honest at work, from sharing a career concern to raising a new idea.
What we found is good news for teams. Many of the factors linked to real loyalty are things teammates and leaders can build together, one conversation at a time.
Teams Are One of the Top Reasons People Stay
Let's start with what's going well. Most employees (82%) say they're likely to be with their employer a year from now. When we asked what keeps them there, the people they work with ranked near the top.
43% of employees say their team is one of the top reasons they stay with their employer.
Only enjoying the work itself ranked higher. The team came in ahead of pay and flexibility, and even ahead of employees' own managers. That's a real strength, and it's something every team can build on.
Still, plans to stay don't always tell the whole story. Roughly one in five employees expect to stay but couldn't clearly say they'd stay if the job market were ideal. We call this the loyalty illusion.
These are people who are staying for now but haven't fully decided this is where they want to be long term. Some may be waiting for a better time to make a move. Others may enjoy their work and their team but feel unsure about where their own path leads. From the outside, they look just as loyal as everyone else.
That doesn't mean they've checked out. It just means their loyalty may depend more on circumstances than on a clear choice to stay. The upside is that doubt isn't set in stone, and the people around someone can play a real part in how they feel about staying.
Doubt Tends to Show Up in the Middle Years
Time with the organization plays a part. Doubt about staying is lowest in an employee's first year, and then it rises.
Doubt about staying rises from 27% in the first year to 40% at 1-5 years.
After about five years, doubt starts to ease again. It drops to 37% for employees who've been there six to ten years and 29% for those who've been there more than ten. That may be partly because people who stay that long have found a role and a team that fits them well, while some who felt less sure may have already moved on.
The early days tend to come with a lot of built-in connection. There's onboarding, plenty to learn, and new teammates to get to know. A few years in, people know the work and the team well, and bigger questions about growth may start to come up. That makes the one-to-five-year window a great time for teams to lean in. A teammate who feels heard and supported during those years may find it easier to picture a future where they are.
Feeling Safe to Speak Up Makes a Big Difference
Psychological safety is the sense that you can speak up or admit a mistake at work without worrying it will be held against you. On a team with high psychological safety, people share ideas and concerns because they trust their teammates. To look at loyalty through a team lens, we grouped employees by how psychologically safe they feel at work. The difference between those groups is striking.
Doubt about staying is 20% with high psychological safety vs. 59% with low.
That means employees who don't feel safe speaking up are about three times as likely to wonder whether they'd stay. Psychological safety can grow too. It's built in small, everyday moments, like how a team reacts when someone shares a half-formed idea or points out a problem no one else has mentioned. Those are moments every person on a team can influence, whether they lead the team or not.
Trust and Healthy Conflict Start with Being Honest
In The Five Behaviors® model, trust is about being open and vulnerable with each other. That might look like admitting a mistake, asking for help, or saying, “ I don’t know.” Productive conflict builds on that trust. It's the ability to debate ideas openly, knowing the team can disagree and still be on the same side.
Our research suggests both are closely tied to loyalty. Employees who aren't sure they can be honest about career concerns are about twice as likely to have doubts about staying as those who feel they can.
Being honest about career concerns doesn't have to mean a big, serious sit-down. It can be as simple as telling your manager, “I'd love to get more experience with client work,” or asking a teammate how they made the move into their current role. Small comments like these open the door, and they give the people around you a chance to help. The same goes for the ideas and concerns that come up day to day. Among employees who held back, nearly half (47%) have doubts about staying.
1 in 3 employees held back an idea or concern in the past year to avoid seeming difficult.
It's a good reminder that the teammate who pushes back on a plan or raises a concern is usually someone who cares. They want the team to get it right, and they feel safe enough to say so.
What Teams Can Do
Respond well when someone speaks up. When a teammate shares an idea or admits a mistake, a little curiosity or a simple thank you goes a long way. Those small reactions help the next person feel safe enough to speak up too.
Make room for “what's next?” conversations. Ask teammates about their goals in regular one-on-ones, not just at review time. This matters most in the first few years, when bigger career questions tend to surface.
Invite healthy debate. Before wrapping up a decision, ask who sees it differently or what might go wrong. Disagreement is a sign people are engaged, and good ideas often come out of it.
Great Teams Give People Reasons to Stay
Strong retention is something to celebrate. The bigger opportunity is building a team where people stay because they want to. That grows from honest conversations about someone’s future and from teammates who feel safe enough to disagree. Programs like The Five Behaviors can help teams build the trust and healthy conflict that make those conversations feel natural.
Wiley’s suite of professional solutions gives organizations a shared language and structure to build teams and workplaces people want to be part of, from building better teams with The Five Behaviors, to making confident hiring decisions with PXT Select®, creating engaged, adaptive cultures with Everything DiSC®, and unlocking leadership potential with The Leadership Challenge®.
Wiley Workplace Intelligence conducts in-depth research on key workplace issues by gathering insights from individual contributors, managers, and leaders. Wiley Workplace Intelligence then analyzes these findings to provide actionable solutions that are shared in our blog.
Did You like This Content?
Join our newsletter to get insights,
updates and more!
Found this post useful? Share it.